Infinite Craft starting elements: what the four basics actually do
Infinite Craft starts you with Water, Fire, Wind and Earth. Everything in the game is built from those four, and the first six combinations decide how smooth the rest of your session goes.
The first combinations that matter
Fire + Water gives Steam; Earth + Wind gives Dust; Dust + Earth gives Planet. The last one is the single best early investment in the game because Planet opens the space branch, which opens Mars, which opens Life. You can read the full Dust and Planet pages to see the chains those nodes lead to.
Order beats creativity early
The temptation is to test jokes: Fire + Fire, Earth + Earth, Wind + Wind. Most of those results are dead ends, and the ones that are not can be reached more cheaply later. In the first twenty minutes the return on combining base results with each other is far higher than combining a base with a novelty result.
After the basics, the decision is between the biological branch (Life โ Human โ animals) and the material branch (metal, glass, fire). Both are worth doing; the biological branch is worth doing first because so many later recipes ask for Life.
The recipes-in-order page lists the nodes in roughly the order you will need them.